Silenced Voices

Growing up in Chile during the military dictatorship of General Augusto Pinochet, Prof. Green witnessed how people in power can silence voices of opposition. She remembers how careful she had to be, even as a child, in interacting with the head of her elementary school. “She was definitely from the era of the dictatorship since the dictatorship had just ended. And I lived back and forth between Chile and the U.S. And even though I'm not the child of exiles, even though my family was repressed, we're not official exiles,” she said.

Green said she remembers worrying that the elementary school’s head was always watching, waiting to get her in trouble. “That gives you a sense of like, how deep the sort of silencing can be (of) a memory when you have to be careful constantly, right? …  And the fear that it instills in the people to not tell these stories, because of the danger to pass on these stories.”

Experiences like their professor’s resonated with the history students.

I wonder why historians don’t pay as much attention to the memory of victims
Will Knight
If some events cannot be accepted even as they occur, how can they be assessed later? How does one write a history of the impossible?
Helen Liu
The narrative which used the sources and archives that included silenced peoples will lack the totality of the truth
Jake Winston
Why is it that certain groups of people's memories prevail in the history books more than others?
Evan Clark

The Nicaraguan Revolution

The Somoza family, led by Anastasio Somoza García, ruled Nicaragua for over 40 years. The Somozas amassed a fortune, exiled their political opponents, and seized land and businesses. By the 1960s, Nicaragua grappled with a political and economic crisis created by the dictatorship’s abuses.  

In these cases of military dictatorships in Latin America when you already have a military dictatorship, it's not just that the military is in power. They change everyone in power. They change who's, you know, who's in the judicial system, judges. They change who's in charge of education. They change teachers. So it's a very kind of systematic change in society. It’s not just that they're in power and they arrest people. Right? It is a whole kind of cultural shift that happens
Prof. Green
Many of the witnesses of history did not choose to stay quiet; they were forced to stay silent because they possess little power in the entire society
Helen Liu

The Sandinista National Liberation Front was founded in 1962 to bring an end to the Somoza rule. Over the next 10 years, the group attacked the Nicaraguan National Guard until the government began to fight back.

Women were key contributors to the rebellion because they relied on their stereotypes of innocence and fragility to elude suspicion. But when the rebel group, known in Nicaragua as FSLN, overthrew the dictatorship in 1979 and established a new government, only male members of the resistance emerged in leadership positions.

Despite equally risking their lives to end the dictatorship, there is unequal remembrance of female FSLN fighters and lack of female representation in government settings … While females might not be given the deserved credit for all their hard work, they have left their mark on Nicaragua by improving basic human rights
Hannah Shiffert
The two profound components of the hierarchy of power and personal bias play a detrimental role in shaping historical narratives, as they silence profound parts of history
Brody Grant
The use of power to change memory into history serves to advance the agenda of those with that power, and so it becomes a necessity to understand and uncover these silences
Caleb Franklin
National Palace, Managua (Nicaragua, 1988).
Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Puerto Rico

But what happens when an entire population is erased? Prof. Green asked her students to wrestle with the idea that some people’s very existence isn’t recognized in their homeland.

Green engaged her students with examples of the silencing of the indigenous Arawak people in the Caribbean and the Taíno in Puerto Rico in particular.

Money and power, cliché concepts as they sound, are the exact reason why history books hide the truth
Helen Liu
Oppressive political agendas created by colonizers caused dramatic change by silencing specific indigenous groups
Will Knight

Spanish colonizers began exploring and conquering the Caribbean in the 16th century. In Puerto Rico, the conquerors pushed Taíno people off their land to claim it for themselves. While the Spaniards killed most of the natives, some survived by escaping to remote areas of the island. But Spanish historians insisted that the group was extinct.

I associate that ... with tragedies having a second death, where both many people will be killed, but then all remembrance of them will also be killed off. This can be seen not only in examples of conquistadors and colonizers in America, but throughout the world in all of history
Jack Johnson
The erasure of a people that would have historical claims to the island if otherwise recognized was important to cementing the colonizer’s narrative
Jake Winston

As years passed, more and more people in Puerto Rico claimed Taíno heritage. They insisted that their ancestors had found ways to escape colonial attacks. The people in power refused to admit that the indigenous group had survived.

Today, Puerto Rican government officials still do not recognize the existence of the Taíno. People with Taíno heritage cannot mark their identity as “indigenous” on the census and other government forms.

What the government is trying to ignore ... is the legacy of colonization on the island
Jake Winston
Lies are told on top of lies, creating an endless loop which challenges the authenticity of history. History, however, deserves to be justly viewed. Covering up what happened would only add salt to the wound. A lesson avoided is not a lesson learned
Helen Liu

Chile

The Spanish people who colonized Chile also erased the stories of native groups who were already there. In Chile, the conquerors recognized the existence of an indigenous group, the Mapuche. But they seized Mapuche land through violence, exploited their labor, and excluded the native people’s voices from the official history of Chile.  

Source: Izquierdo S., Salvador.Besnard, Julio.Rojas Huneeus, Francisco., CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
With the Mapuche’s defeat, their land was auctioned off to Chileans and other immigrants. The Mapuche struggled not only to survive in the face of the Chileans but also to preserve their cultural significance in history
Will Knight
The history and suffering of this group have been surgically removed from the historical narrative by the power of the state but lives on in the cultural memory whose trauma reaches through the generations
Caleb Franklin
Historical memory has been foundational in battling national governments for indigenous recognition and legitimization in Puerto Rico and Chile. Neither has been fully successful in their goals, but if they do not utilize the inherent power in recentering narratives, then the erasure of their people will continue without any notice. Power dynamics exist in all countries between communities, but in reclamation projects historical memory has become a powerful and necessary tool to scrutinize power
Jake Winston
Sometimes, in order to justify unjustifiable violence, history is banished from the collective imagination
Grace Kim